Showing posts with label minimum wage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label minimum wage. Show all posts

Living Wages Are Ethical And Good for Society - A Lesson in Humanistic Business Management

I talk politics with people a lot. Rationally and civilly and I realize this may make me an oddity. But if we don't rationally discuss public policy - our public policy won't be rational.

One of the discussions I have fairly regularly has to do with the purpose of a minimum wage.  Some people seem to think that this is an introductory wage. For teens entering the workforce. The minimum wage laws were actually enacted to make sure that no one who worked - would work for starvation wages and excessive hours. In other words, the minimum wage is to ensure that labor - is not exploited.

According to FDR - who helped get this law passed - the law freed industry from "dishonorable competition brought about not only by overworking and underpaying labor, but by destructive business practices."  - https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/message-congress-the-gains-under-nra

He goes on to say that because of the minimum wage law - "business itself recognizes more clearly than at any previous time in our history the advantages and the obligations of cooperation and self-discipline, and the patriotic need of ending unsound financing and unfair practices of all kinds."

In other words, there are greedy bad people running businesses and those bad people exploit the laws. They cheat. Not only their business partners, but their employees. They cheat everyone. And this cheating, drives wages down and that hurts - everyone. Because if employees are living on starvation wages - they not only suffer, the country suffers as no one but the very wealthy can afford to consume. We have to continually protect our businesses against what FDR calls "incorrigible minorities."

Minimum wages and living wages are a necessary topic of conversation for people concerned about Humanistic Business Practices. And FDR's warnings are just as valid today as when he first shared them.

"We must continue to recognize that incorrigible minorities within an industry, or in the whole field of trade and industry, should not be allowed to write the rules of unfair play and compel all others to compete upon their low level. We must make certain that the privilege of cooperating to prevent unfair competition will not be transformed into a license to strangle fair competition under the apparent sanction of the law. Small enterprises especially should be given added protection against discrimination and oppression."

We should recognize people who request the right to oppress and exploit other people for what they are. Incorrigible Minorities.

I had the pleasure of interviewing Prof. Ben Teehankee on this topic a few weeks ago.  In the meantime, if you are in a position to fix people's wages - please do not exploit them to gain an unfair advantage. Ethical wages and good jobs  - benefits your company and our society and the race to the bottom is only promoted by people who incorrigible people. Let's not join them on their race to the bottom.



A Rational Minimum Wage Proposal

The goal: a relatively objective process, as opposed to just picking a number that sounds good


Charles Lane of the Washington Post authored a really interesting essay on the minimum wage. Here it is: http://www.bradenton.com/opinion/national-opinions/article158853904.html

His proposal:

Consider: Since 1938, the federal minimum wage has not exceeded 54 percent of average private-sector hourly wages, a level it hit in 1968, nor fallen below 28 percent, which is where the $7.25 federal minimum ranks today. 
The midpoint between those extremes is 41 percent, a number that felicitously resembles ratios between minimum and average wages in other advanced industrial countries. 
Multiplying 41 percent by the current average hourly wage, $26.22, yields a new federal minimum of $10.75. Phase it in over a few years, index it to wage growth or an equivalent factor - and move on to less contentious topics like health care, or how many angels can dance on the head of a pin.

I LOVE this proposal.  First some background on why.

The minimum wage is designed to ensure that workers can afford basic necessities. It’s not an entry level wage – it’s supposed to be a living wage because in capitalist systems, wages tend to depress and that’s a problem because when wages are too low – people can no longer consumer and if you have no consumers, you have no business.

Setting a minimum wage helps ensure that no one cheats by paying employees less and all of society benefits from having wage earners who can actually support themselves without subsidy from tax payers and who can also afford to consume the goods and services created by a society.  People opposed to the minimum wage shouldn’t call themselves capitalists.

Mr. Lane’s proposal is reasonable, rational and can be tied to average wages, has some reasonable rational math to back it up and if implemented would mean that we NEVER have to have this debate again.   It can also be set at the state level  so that the variations in average wages are taken into account.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...